Expensive Money Means Slower Economic Growth
Christopher Norwood • February 24, 2025

Executive Summary

  • The S&P finished the week at 6,013.13
  • Volatility is still low despite last week's rise to 18.21
  • The tech sector is trailing the S&P
  • More stocks are participating in the U.S. stock market gains
  • International & Emerging markets are outperforming the U.S. markets
  • Interesting Charts below




The Stock Market

S&P 5-Day Chart

The S&P 500 lost 1.7% last week, finishing at 6,013.13. Friday was a straight-down day with a close near the day’s low. Follow-through selling is likely in the week ahead. The index did hold the 50-day moving average (chart below). The 50-day may provide some support on Monday, at least initially. The Dow Jones Industrial Average had its worst week of the year.

S&P 6-Month Chart

Volatility is still low despite rising last week. The VIX closed the week at 18.21, up from 15.37. The VIX has remained below its long-term average of 20 on a closing basis since December, according to Ulrike Hoffmann-Burchardi, chief investment officer of global equities at UBS Global Wealth Management. The so-called fear gauge has remained in the 15 to 16 range most of the year.


Complacency also has extended to bonds, according to Stan Shipley, Evercore ISI’s fixed-income strategist. “Despite a daily barrage of policy initiatives from Washington and higher readings of economic policy uncertainty, the MOVE index, a metric of implied Treasury volatility, has fallen sharply this year and is near prior low readings over the past two years,” he wrote in a client note on Friday. Given these risks, UBS’ Hoffmann-Burchardi writes, volatility is one asset class that is mispriced, “given the potential political, geopolitical, and technological shifts that are likely to unfold in the months ahead.” 



Wall Street is expecting volatility to rise in the coming weeks. High volatility follows low volatility like night follows day. The difference is that the timing is less predictable. The trick is figuring out what will trigger the high volatility. For now, volatility remains low, and the S&P continues to grind higher.

S&P 500 2-Year Chart

There is change happening underneath the surface of the market though. The Magnificent Seven isn’t so magnificent anymore. The MAGS ETF is down 1.5% year-to-date, trailing the S&P by 3.74%. Also, the tech sector (XLK) is up only 1.01% while the S&P is up 2.24%. Health Care (XLV) is the best-performing sector year-to-date with a return of 6.44%. “Over the past two years, we’ve had healthcare underperform by the largest amount that we have seen in more than three decades,” says Andy Acker, manager of the Janus Henderson Global Life Science fund. “That’s a very unusual situation.”


Energy (XLE) has returned 6.15%. Utilities (XLU) has returned 6.05%. Even stodgy Consumer Staples (XLP) has joined the party with a return of 4.54% year-to-date. Communications Services (XLC) is up 6.41%, but META isn’t leading the sector higher anymore. T-Mobile has returned 20.13% on the year. Fox and AT&T have also outperformed META in 2025.



It appears the concentrated stock returns of 2023/24 may be a thing of the past.

And it isn’t just the 493 forgotten U.S. stocks that are coming to life. International and emerging markets have shown a pulse as well.

International stocks have been trailing the U.S. for a very long time. Hartford Funds pointed out recently that the U.S. outperformance cycle has been about eight years on average since 1975. The current cycle has U.S. stocks outperforming international stocks for almost fourteen years.

The dismal foreign stock performance has left them trading cheaply. The MSCI EMU index of large- and mid-cap European stocks trades for about 14 times expected 12-month forward earnings. That's less than two-thirds the 22x forward price/earnings multiple of the S&P 500. The U.S. now represents almost 70% of the world’s equity-market valuation but only 25% of the world economy. The disparity between market capitalization and economic size won’t last forever.


The gap is already closing. The Vanguard FTSE Europe ETF (VGK) has returned 10.18% in 2025, while the S&P 500 is only up 2.40%. The iShares MSCI Germany ETF (EWG) has returned an even greater 12.85% this year. The outperformance could continue for a while. There's lots of pessimism about foreign stocks. It won't take much good news to push overseas markets higher. Meanwhile S&P 500 earnings growth estimates are optimistic. The consensus is for earnings growth of 10.1% in 2025 and 14.0% in 2026. Disappointment could pull U.S. markets lower.


And in fact, U.S. earnings growth estimates are falling. The forward 4-quarter estimate ended this week at $270.46, versus last week’s $271.24 and January 3rd’s $272.67. The 12-month forward P/E ratio is now 22.6x vs. 22.2x and January 3rd’s 21.8x.


The S&P 500 earnings yield (inverse of P/E) is now 4.42%, versus 4.5% last week, and 4.6% as of January 3rd 2025. The 10-year Treasury yield is 4.43%. The S&P 500 earnings yield at 4.42% with the 10-year yield at 4.43% means a lot is riding on continued strong earnings growth. Otherwise, it is difficult to justify owning the stock market instead of bonds.


The year is young and trends can change. At the moment though, it looks as if 2025 will break the pattern held in 2023-24. Concentrated performance from a handful of U.S. stocks has been the order of the day. That dynamic appears to be giving way to broader returns in the U.S. It also seems 2025 could see the continued resurgence of foreign stocks, both developed and emerging.


Interesting Charts

The 10-year real yield is currently 2.05% (Feb. 21), according to treasury.gov. The 5-year real yield is 1.68%. Real yields are as high as they’ve been since the Great Recession. Real yields are the real cost of money. Expensive money means slower economic growth all else equal.

Corporate profit margins are high (black line below). Profit margins are mean reverting. Declining profit margins would lead to earnings growth disappointment in the U.S. in 2025.

Falling inflation should mean falling profit growth (chart below).

S&P 500 companies get a large percentage of revenue from overseas. Tariffs will make U.S. exports more expensive if other countries retaliate.

Offsetting at least some of those headwinds, financial conditions remain loose (chart below). A negative number means financial conditions are looser than average. You will note that financial conditions have been looser than average for most of the last 35 years. It's also worth noting that cheap money leads to high debt.

The money supply is growing again. (black line in chart below)

Money supply growth impacts inflation according to the Quantity Theory of Money. The chart below shifts M2 growth forward 12 months. In other words, M2 growth impacts inflation with about a 12-month lag.

The Federal Reserve is signaling that it’s on hold. It almost certainly should be.


Regards,


Christopher R Norwood, CFA



Chief Market Strategist

By Christopher Norwood March 4, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P finished the week at 5,954.50 High government spending has kept the economy growing The S&P has been trading sideways for four months now The Magnificent 7 and technology are out. Healthcare, Financials, Real Estate, and Consumer Staples are in Uncertainty is high Interesting Charts below  The Stock Market The S&P 500 lost 1.0% last week, closing at 5,954.50. The Nasdaq fell 3.4% during the week. Treasury yields continued to fall. The 10-year Treasury closed the week at 4.21%. The two-year Treasury yield dropped to 4.01%. The 3-month yield ended the week at 4.34%. The yield curve inverted once more. The 3M/10Yr curve inversion increases the chance of a recession in the next 12-18 months. Of course, the curve was already inverted until last December when it began to normalize. The 3M/10Yr curve last inverted in late October 2022. The period from October 2022 until December 2024 marked the longest continuous stretch of inversion since 1962. And yet no recession materialized, at least it hasn't yet. The lack of a recession in 2023/24 was most likely because of massive fiscal spending. The federal government has run large deficits since the pandemic. Government spending was $6.9 trillion in 2024, almost 25% of GDP. The government's deficit spending has kept the economy growing.
By Christopher Norwood February 17, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P finished the week at 6,114.69 The 2-year yield hit 4.38% after the Consumer Price Index (CPI) was released on Wednesday, but ended the week at 4.27% Investors dumped stocks when the CPI report was released Producer Price Index (PPI) has accelerated for five straight months PPI is a leading indicator of consumer inflation Inflation expectations are rising among fixed-income investors The 5- &10-year breakevens are rising The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood February 10, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P finished the week at 6025.99 The S&P has been trading sideways since 11 November Volatility (VIX) has spiked five times since last fall each time falling quickly back to mid-teen levels Microsoft, Alphabet, and Amazon have contributed to the negative tone with cautious guidance The Equity Risk Premium has been falling over the last 14 years Bonds have been a horrible investment over the last three, five, and ten years The jobs market continues to show strength Consumers' inflation expectations are increasing The stock market is expensive and will return less than its long-term average over the next decade Good stock picking will be critical if investors are to earn a return close to the long run average. The equity risk premium is too low which may make Treasury bonds a better investment than stocks on a risk adjusted basis over the next decade. Treasury bonds may outperform stocks over the next decade but not necessarily over the next few years since the 10-Year could rise another 100 basis points in the short term. The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood February 3, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P fell 1% last week, closing Friday at 6,040.53 The index hasn’t been able to break clear of resistance The AI space took a big hit Monday Tariffs on Canada, Mexico, and China GDP grew 2.3% annually in Q4 The futures market expected the funds rate to remain at 4.25-4.50% and it did The employment cost index (ECI) for Q4 2024 rose 0.9% QoQ Pending home sales took a hit in December The stock market continues to trend higher There is a relationship between the stock market and the economy More Interesting Charts to review 
By Christopher Norwood January 27, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P hit a new high on Thursday, reaching 6,128.18. The Volatility Index (VIX) fell to a low of 14.85 The VIX has declined sharply from 27.6 The 5.4% decline from 6 December to 13 January doesn’t qualify as a correction Watch Earnings, Inflation, and Interest Rates for the stock market's near-term direction Don't miss the Charts Worth Seeing at the bottom
By Christopher Norwood January 20, 2025
Executive Summary The stock market's best week since Donald Trump’s re-election in November The S&P 500 rose 2.91% The CME FedWatch tool is predicting one cut in 2025 The fundamental narrative was all about inflation Earnings season is in full swing starting this week Higher than-expected interest rates and inflation might put downward pressure on stocks. Inflation expectations have been rising 2025 is likely to be a volatile year for the capital markets Deglobalization means higher inflation
By Christopher Norwood January 13, 2025
Executive Summary The jobs report on Friday sparked stock and bond market selling Economic data hasn't justified rate cuts The Bond market has been signaling its disagreement with the Fed since the September cut The 10-year Treasury Yield is rising. Bond investors see inflation risks The Jobs market is strong Disinflation is slowing Investors should expect more volatility in 2025 Diversification means less portfolio volatility but also lower returns True diversification means always owning something that is underperforming  Diversified portfolios will trail during a bull market
By Christopher Norwood January 6, 2025
Executive Summary The Santa Claus rally was a no-show this year Friday's jobs report might bring volatility Economic data continues to point toward a strong economy The stock market is near all-time highs Corporate bond spreads are near record tights Liquidity is abundant No signs of a recession. The Fed is backing away from aggressive rate cuts. Inflation concerns are re-emerging  2024 in Review
By Christopher Norwood December 23, 2024
Executive Summary The Stock Market dropped 2% last week The Dow ended its losing streak at 10 The Fed cut interest rates by a quarter-point last Wednesday Fewer rate cuts could mean slower economic growth and slower earnings growth Apollo’s chief economist Torsten Sløk predicts a 40% chance of Fed rate hikes in 2025 Value stocks continue to lag growth stocks and the overall market Value will make a comeback. It always does. History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes~ Mark Twain
By Christopher Norwood December 16, 2024
Executive Summary 50-years of S&P 500 data The Dow ended Friday on a seven-day losing streak 96% chance the Fed will cut by 0.25% this week Stock market strategists are expecting more S&P 500 gains in 2025 Value Investing Outperforms over the Long Run Value can be found in international and emerging markets today Value can be found in the U.S. stock market, but it takes patience
More Posts
Share by: