WHY DON'T MORE PEOPLE USE ANNUITIES?
April 27, 2019
Businessman Drinking a Cup of Coffee — Fishers, IN — Norwood Economics

FIXED INCOME ANNUITIES LOCK IN CASH FLOW IN RETIREMENT.

So why don’t more people use them?

FROM THE BLEACHERS, VOL. 17

MARKET UPDATE

The S&P 500 set a record on a closing basis Friday, finishing the week at 2939.88. The index sits just below its all-time high of 2940.91. A close above the old high would be considered bullish by traders and many money managers alike and could well lead to an attempt to take out the big round 3,000 number just 2% above the current all-time high. Earnings reports continue to come in better than expected. About half of the S&P 500 companies have reported and earnings growth is averaging 2%, according to Barron’s, much better than the original forecast of a 3.8% decline. Furthermore, fully 80% of the companies that have reported have beat earnings estimates, a higher percentage than normal. Of course, companies have been meeting and beating much reduced estimates, as companies and analysts continue to play the earnings expectations game; lower estimates to the point that beating them becomes highly likely, declare the earnings beat a positive event, and hope investors believe it and buy.


There have been some notable misses however. 3M was hammered on Thursday, falling 13% after a poor earnings report. It was 3M’s worst single day loss in more than a decade. Likewise Intel dropped 9% on Friday after providing weak guidance for the rest of the year. 3M has broad exposure to both the U.S. and Asian economies while Intel still commands approximately 90% market share in microprocessors used for PCs, laptops, and servers. Big misses and weak guidance by big, economically important companies are often meaningful indicators of underlying economic activity. 


On the other hand, Q1 GDP rose by 3.2%, much better than expected and a sharp improvement over the 2.2% growth in Q4. Morgan Stanley economists are expecting only 1.1% GDP growth in Q2 however, as Q1 GDP growth benefited from factors that aren’t sustainable and might even contribute to slower Q2 growth as those factors reverse. A sharp increase in inventory, for instance, added 0.7% to Q1 growth. Stripping out the increase in inventories drops Q1 GDP to 2.5%. Likewise, government spending increased by 2.4% annualized, reversing a 0.4% contraction in Q4 2018 spending. The government is on track to run a 2019 budget deficit of around $1 trillion or 5% of GDP, clearly an unsustainable number. Core spending, private domestic final sales, was only 1.3% in Q1 and is likely more indicative of what’s to come. It was the weakest private domestic final sales number in years.


The market always seems to surprise, so it’s entirely possible we’ll see a continued rise into year end, building on the already 17% gain in the S&P 500, but it’s less likely than a pullback at this point, given market valuations and slower underlying economic growth.

INVESTING – THE ANNUITIZATION PUZZLE

Accumulation annuities are typically expensive, restrictive, and undesirable if your goal is to create wealth for retirement. Fixed immediate payout annuities, on the other hand, are extremely useful and effective at helping solve your cash flow needs in retirement. Deferred fixed income annuities are even more useful at reducing or eliminating longevity risk. The puzzle is why more people don’t use them. 


“Rational choice theory predicts that households will find annuities attractive at the onset of retirement because they address the risk of outliving one’s income,” write Benartzi, Previtero, and Thaler in their 2011 paper about the annuitization puzzle. Longevity risk is the primary problem solved by fixed immediate annuities. Longevity risk is the risk of outliving your assets. A man age 65 has a 50/50 chance of living to 82 and a woman to 85. One in ten men retiring at age 65 will live another 27 years while one in ten women will live another 30 years. 


Immediate payout annuities are an insurance policy that allows you to increase consumption while reducing longevity risk. They work because people who die early are subsidizing those who live longer, which is also likely why many people aren’t keen on handing over a lump sum in exchange for lifetime cash flow. Loss aversion is well documented. We feel the pain of a loss around twice as much as any pleasure we receive from gains. The idea of dying prematurely and “losing” money on an immediate annuity as a result is a major turn off for people. The “loss” is the result of not collecting all of the payments that you would have received had you lived to the actuarially expected age. Of course, it’s no more a loss than if someone pays on a term life insurance policy for decades and then lets it lapse due to rising premiums and a declining need for life insurance.


Social security is the best immediate payout annuity available. Waiting until you turn 70 to capture the larger annuity is almost always the better choice. Social security is even inflation adjusted, which isn’t true of private annuities. Everyone then does have at least one immediate payout annuity in retirement as long as they are eligible for social security. The question is whether a second, private immediate payout annuity or deferred income annuity is appropriate, using a portion of your investable assets, to increase guaranteed cash flow to better cover necessary expenses in retirement. The answer is it depends. Too little liquid wealth makes it unwise to tie up a lump sum in a stream of future payments to you, while substantial liquid wealth makes it unnecessary to tie up a lump sum in a stream of payments to you. For the folks in between, however, buying an immediate or deferred income annuity with a portion of their liquid wealth can increase their ability to consume in retirement without increasing the risk of running out of money. 


Regards,


Christopher R Norwood, CFA


Chief Market Strategist

By Christopher Norwood June 30, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 3.4% last week, climbing to 6,173.07 The Magnificent 7 are outperforming the S&P 493 by over 18% since April The Cboe Volatility Index (VIX) fell as low as 16.11 last week Investors seem unconcerned about tariffs and war Treasury interest rates are starting to fall The Fed has little reason to cut if unemployment isn't moving higher The stock market is at record highs Corporate bond spreads are tight, meaning credit is abundant The dollar has fallen by around 10% in 2025 Inflation is expected to move higher because of tariff The Stock Market The S&P 500 rose 3.4% last week. The Israeli-Iranian ceasefire was credited with the surge to the upside. The index had lost 0.7% over the prior two weeks.
By Christopher Norwood June 23, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 gained 0.3% last week, climbing to 5,967.84 The index is having trouble staying above 6,000 Technical indicators are turning somewhat negative The Federal Reserve kept the overnight rate at 4.25% - 4.50% The updated “dot plot” shows a divided Fed Seven members indicate no rate cuts in 2025 Eight members forecast two rate cuts in 2025 The Fed is forecasting a slower economy in 2025 and 2026 The hard data is starting to point to a slowing economy Inflation is still well above the Fed’s 2% target
By Christopher Norwood June 16, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 fell 0.4% last week to finish at 5,976.97 Friday's sell-off due to Israel's attack on Iran The Volatility Index (VIX) is rising due to the war in the Middle East Higher volatility is usually associated with a down move in the market There is no chance of a Fed Funds Rate cut at this week’s meeting according to the CME FedWatch Tool The unemployment rate has been rising slowly The dollar continues to weaken The U.S. needs to reduce its spending to avoid a currency crisis  The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood June 9, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 1.5% last week to finish at 6,000.36 The May payroll number came in above estimates The U.S. economy is slowing, despite the S&P 500 poking above 6,000 The Labor Force Participation Rate fell to 62.4% from 62.6% Inflation may have bottomed and is set to rise The services price paid index is pointing towards a higher CPI The declining dollar is a concern Tariffs are a tax The Q2 nowcast seems to be indicating that negative economic impacts from tariffs won’t affect Q2 International markets have far outperformed U.S. markets so far in 2025 The Stock Market The S&P 500 climbed 1.5% last week and closed at 6,000.36. The Dow rose 1.3% while the Nasdaq rose 2.0%. Interest rates rose as bond prices fell. A stronger-than-expected jobs report on Friday is getting the blame for rising yields. The jobs report was also responsible for the S&P’s gap-up open on Friday (chart below).
By Christopher Norwood June 2, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 1.9% last week to finish at 5911.69 The S&P 500 rose 6%, the Dow rose 3.8% and the Nasdaq climbed nearly10% in May Could see another test of support around 5,800 this week Several longer-term negative divergences may be pointing to a tough summer Declining new highs during an advancing market is a negative Earnings estimates for 2025 and 2026 have been trending lower Earnings drive the stock market over the long run
By Christopher Norwood June 2, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 fell 2.6% last week to close at 5,802.82. The 20-Year Treasury auction went poorly. The yield rose above 5%. The 5% threshold has twice this year resulted in the administration adjusting its stance on tariffs. (Make that three times as Trump over the weekend gives the U.K. until July 9 th .) Longer-term inflation expectations are rising. Moody’s downgraded the U.S. to Aa1 on 16 May. The credit default swaps market sees the U.S. as a Baa1/BBB+ credit, on par with Greece. The tax cut bill will add to the deficits and debt. Long-term interest rates might well continue to rise.
By Christopher Norwood May 19, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 5.3% last week to finish at 5,958.38 The Dow advanced 3.4% and the Nasdaq added 7.2% A falling VIX means investor confidence is increasing A 90-day pause in the trade war sent the S&P higher Earnings estimates are falling along with GDP growth forecasts Earnings and interest rates drive the stock market over the long run Investors are chasing performance Small business hiring plans and job openings haven’t improved Norwood Economics continues to look for good companies on sale The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood May 19, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 fell 0.5%, to finish at 5,659.91 The Dow fell 0.3%, and the Nasdaq dropped 0.5% The 200-day moving average is the next resistance U.S. nominal GDP growth expected to slow significantly Bank of America shifts investment focus Norwood Economics already has exposure to gold for most clients Norwood Economics is overweight international stocks The risk of both higher unemployment and higher inflation has increased The Federal Reserve declined to lower the fed funds rate last week The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood May 5, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 2.9% last week to finish at 5,686.67 The Dow was up 3% last week, and the Nasdaq rose 3.4% The counter-trend rally is ongoing Investors are extremely bearish due to worries about the trade war Political prediction markets are back Exploding imports are not a sign of weakening demand The April jobs report was better than expected The Trade War continues Capital is flowing into international and emerging markets The US dollar will likely continue to weaken The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood April 28, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 4.6% last week and finished at 5,525.21 Dollar weakness is an unpleasant surprise Tariffs and the dollar's safe-haven status should have pushed the dollar higher The S&P managed to retake the 20-day moving average Investors are looking for a reason to buy Some strategists are advising to sell the bounce Negative supply shocks are bad for the economy Weakness in U.S. bonds, stocks, and the dollar has investors scared Data is beginning to point to an economic slowdown The Chicago Fed National Activity Index (CFNAI) is one of the most important and overlooked economic indicators The Stock Market The S&P 500 rose 4.6% last week and finished at 5,525.21. The Dow rose 2.5% and the Nasdaq gained 6.7%. The S&P’s gains were attributed to President Trump’s statements at a Tuesday press conference. He said that Chinese tariffs would come down, and he wouldn’t fire Fed Chairman Jerome Powell. The 10-year Treasury yield ended the week at 4.25%. The two-year Treasury yield finished at 3.79%. The dollar rebounded. The dollar index (DXY) ended the week at 99.587. It hit a 3-year low of 97.921 on Monday. The DXY has lost 9.6% since mid-January. Tariffs and the dollar's safe-haven status should have pushed the dollar higher, not lower. It is believed that foreigners are repatriating their money. America needs foreign capital. Interest rates will have to go higher to entice foreign capital to our shores if safe-haven status is lost.
More Posts